Nina had agreed to organize the winter fundraiser at Willow House on one condition: she would not have to work with Theo Mercer. The condition lasted until Tuesday, when the committee chair called to explain that their caterer had cancelled and Theo was the only chef available within their modest budget. By Wednesday evening, he was standing in the community kitchen with a notebook and the same infuriatingly calm expression she remembered. They had not spoken properly in four years. Back then, Theo had accepted a job in another city, and Nina had mistaken his awkward invitation for an afterthought. Neither of them had asked the question that might have changed what happened next. Now they discussed tablecloths and allergies as though those were the only subjects between them. The fundraiser needed to serve sixty guests, and Nina had promised that every ticket would help replace the building's leaking roof. Theo proposed a three-course menu built around local produce. She questioned the cost of the dessert; he offered to make the pear tart himself. Their conversation became easier when there was something practical to solve. On the night before the event, a power cut interrupted their preparations. They carried the unfinished place settings into the hall and worked by the light of two battery lanterns. Theo admitted that he had written to her after leaving, then deleted the message because he was afraid she would not reply. Nina stopped folding a napkin and told him she would have. For a while, neither said anything more. Rain tapped against the windows, and somewhere above them the roof continued its patient complaint. When Theo asked whether she would have dinner with him after the fundraiser, Nina smiled at the long rows of empty chairs. This time, she said, he would have to reserve a table for two.